thesis

"Afin qu'il y ait mémoire de moi" : sens et structure dans l'Historia verdadera de Bernal Di'az del Castillo

Defense date:

Jan. 1, 1991

Edit

Institution:

Paris 3

Disciplines:

Authors:

Abstract EN:

The true history of the conquest of new spain is one of the most widely read histories covering the period of the discovery and conquest of mexico; it is also one of the most important historical sources for this period; due to this fact, numerous historians have studied the historical aspects of bernal diaz's work and its value as a historical source. Our approach has been, thus; different since we mainly aimed at studying the expressive and literary quality of the text; the historia verdadera, as the original title reads, was written between 1545 (we maintain) and 1568 with the confessed aim of setting the record right and of putting down in writing for posterity the deeds and sufferings of the men that were faithful to hernan bortes all along; bernal diaz achieved his goal and convinced most of his readers of the justice of his case; by studying the rhetorical and argumentative structure of his work we have been able to interpret it as a whole and to judge in accordance with the qims set by the author for his text. Following horace's dictum, the historia verdadera convinces because it pleases.

Abstract FR:

La veritable histoire de la conquete de la nouvelle espagne est une des chronique des indes les plus lues; elle est aussi la source principale pour la conquete du mexique. De nombreuses etudes historiques ont ete menees sur l'oeuvre, et sa valeur comme source a ete aussi examinee. Notre approche, donc, a ete different et nous avons approchee le texte depuis l'angle de sa qualite expressive et litteraire. La historia verdadera (titre original) n'est pas, comme on a voulu le soutenir, une oeuvre ingenue, transparente et chaotique, produit de la nostalgie d'un vieillard qui ne pouvait pas s'arreter d'ecrire. Ce n'est pas non plus une histoire ratee ni un roman avorte. L'historia verdadera est le dernier stratageme dont se sert bernal diaz pour nous presenter son cas sous une lumiere favorable, et il y parvient. Ce succes, dont temoigne l'impact de l'oeuvre durant quatre siecles, ne repose pas sur les faits historiques eux-memes, mais bien plutot sur la forme. Bernal diaz reussit ce qui etait le critere de la litterature du siecle d'or: "aprovechar deleitando".