thesis

Contribution à l'étude de matériaux littéraires pro et antisémites en Grande-Bretagne (1870-1983) : le mythe du complot juif. Les protocoles des sages de Sion, le cas d'Israëli

Defense date:

Jan. 1, 1987

Edit

Institution:

Paris 13

Disciplines:

Abstract EN:

In a difficult social, economic and political context, the jewish community of great britain, from 1970 onwards, was often accused of jeopardizing the stability of the country. In 1920, the publication of the protocols of the elders of zion bore out, for some antisemites this accusation. Widely commented upon in the press, that antisemitic forgery cooked up by the russian secret service to bring discredit upon the jews and to be used for internal political manoeuvring was supposed to expose the scheme drawn up by the jews to dominate the world. Although it was proved in 1921 that the protocols were a forgery, up to now 87 editions have been published in great britain. Based on the most hackneyed stereotypes and on a skilful point of view technique, that book was exploited in many writings that aimed at proving the actuality of the jewish plot. Along with the exploitation of the protocols, these writings claim to give further evidence of the plot by gleaning examples here and there in occult history, in the bible, and in contemporary world affairs. In spite of an apparent logic, the method used by the antisemites can easily be exposed : a hotch-potch of historical facts, a constant use of anachronisms, garbled and falsified quotations. The distortion of part of disraeli's work further illustrates this method. Disraeli, a philosemite, whose racial ideas are quite debatable, is set up as a " prophet " of the jewish world plot by some antisemites.

Abstract FR:

Dans un contexte social, economique et politique difficile, les juifs de grandebretagne, a partir de 1870, furent accuses souvent de mettre en peril le pays. La parution en 1920 des protocoles des sages de sion apporta a certains la preuve de la validite de leurs accusations. Largement commente par la presse, ce faux antisemite fabrique par les services secrets russes pour discrediter les juifs et servir a des manoeuvres politiques internes, etait cense reveler le plan des juifs pour dominer le monde. En depit des preuves avancees pour demontrer la faussete de ce document en 1921, 87 editions anglaises ont paru de 1920 a nos jours. Tablant sur les stereotypes les plus ecules, et sur une adroite technique du point de vue, ce livre servit de pretexte a toute une litterature visant a prouver l'existence du complot juif. En plus de l'exploitation des protocoles, ces ouvrages pretendent apporter d'autres 'preuves' puisees ca et la dans l'histoire occulte, la bible, la situation mondiale actuelle. Sous une logique apparente, la methode utilisee par les antisemites transparait vite : amalgames, anachronismes, tronquages, trucages. La deformation d'une partie de l'oeuvre de disraeli en donne un autre exemple revelateur : disraeli, le philosemite aux conceptions raciales discutables devient sous la plume des antisemites le 'prophete' du pretendu complot juif.